Can You Put Permanent Dye Over Semi-Permanent Hair Color?

Can You Put Permanent Dye Over Semi-Permanent Hair Color?

Short answer: yes, you can put permanent hair dye over semi-permanent color. Semi-permanent dye only coats the outside of the hair and fades with washing, while permanent dye is mixed with developer and changes the hair colour more fully. The result depends on the shade you have now, so bright or dark semi-permanent colours can show through the new colour.

Many people try a semi-permanent shade, change their mind and want something longer lasting. The good news is that you do not have to wait for it to grow out. This guide shows what colour you will really get, how long to wait, and how to apply permanent dye over semi-permanent colour step by step.

Semi-permanent vs demi-permanent vs permanent dye

Knowing how each type works explains why layering them behaves the way it does.

Semi-permanentDemi-permanentPermanent
Mixed with developer?NoYes, low strengthYes
What it doesCoats the outside of the hairDeposits colour, gentlyChanges colour more fully, can lighten
How long it lastsFades over several washesFades over a few weeksLasts until it grows out
Can it lighten hair?NoNoYes
Good forTrying a shade, tints, fashion colourRefreshing colour, blendingLong-lasting colour, covering grey

Because semi-permanent dye does not lift, it is the colour that will show through when you go over it, not the other way around.

What colour will you get?

The shade you have now matters more than the one on the box. Use this as a guide, and always do a strand test.

Your semi-permanent colourNew permanent colourWhat to expect
Natural brown or black tintA similar or darker brown or blackSmooth, even result
Red or copperBlonde or light brownWarm, red or orange tones may show through
Pink or pastelLight blondeOften pale pink or peach cast
Blue, green or purpleBrownCan look muddy or carry a faint green or blue tint
Vivid fashion shadeAnything lighterColour may stay patchy, so fade the semi-permanent first
Black semi-permanentAnything lighterWill not lighten, so expect it to stay dark

Going the same depth or darker is the safest option. Going lighter over a strong semi-permanent colour is where surprises happen. If you are heading for a dark shade, our guide on how to dye your hair jet black has more tips.

How long should you wait before using permanent dye?

You can apply permanent dye over semi-permanent colour straight away if the colours work together, for example brown over a brown tint. If you want a very different result, wait until the semi-permanent has faded as much as possible, which usually takes a few washes. A bright fashion colour should be faded first so it does not tint the new shade.

How to fade semi-permanent color first

If you want a cleaner base, speed the fading up:

  1. Wash with a clarifying shampoo two or three times over several days.
  2. Use warm water, which lifts colour faster than cool water.
  3. Avoid colour-depositing conditioners while you wait.
  4. Skip heavy conditioning masks until the colour has faded, because they slow the fading down.

If the colour will not budge, a salon can use a colour remover or recommend a shade that works over the top. Our guide to getting rid of the Color Oops smell is useful if you use a remover at home.

How to apply permanent dye over semi-permanent color

  1. Strand test first. Mix a small amount of dye and colour one hidden section. Wait the full development time and check the shade in daylight.
  2. Follow the box instructions. This includes any skin test the maker asks you to carry out before colouring.
  3. Start with clean, dry hair that is free of heavy oils and styling products.
  4. Section your hair and apply colour to the roots first, unless the box says otherwise.
  5. Add the rest through the lengths and ends once the roots have started to develop.
  6. Watch the timer. Leaving dye on longer than directed can make colour darker or uneven. See what happens if you leave hair dye on too long.
  7. Rinse until the water runs clear, then use the conditioner that comes with the kit.

Can you put semi-permanent dye over permanent dye?

Yes, and this is the more common direction. Semi-permanent dye can add tone or a fashion shade over permanent colour, as long as the new colour is the same depth or darker. It will not lighten hair. Because it only coats the outside, it fades more quickly than permanent colour.

Can you mix semi-permanent and permanent dye?

Do not mix them in the same bowl unless the product tells you to. Developer is part of the permanent formula, and combining it with direct dyes can change both. A colourist can use different products together, which is why a salon is a good option for a custom shade.

When to see a colourist

Ask a professional if:

  • Your hair is bleached, highlighted or has bands of different colour
  • You want to go much lighter than your current shade
  • You have bright blue, green or purple semi-permanent colour you want to remove
  • You have tried to colour it twice and the result keeps going wrong

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you put permanent hair dye over semi-permanent dye?

Yes. Permanent dye can go over semi-permanent colour, but the old shade may show through, especially if it is bright or dark. Do a strand test first.

How long should I wait to dye over semi-permanent?

If the colours work together you can dye straight away. For a big colour change, let the semi-permanent fade for a few washes first.

Will permanent dye cover semi-permanent dye?

Usually, when the new colour is the same depth or darker. Lighter permanent colour can show warm, muddy or tinted tones from the old shade.

Can you put semi-permanent dye over permanent dye?

Yes, if the semi-permanent shade is the same depth or darker than your hair. It will not lift the colour.

Does semi-permanent dye wash out?

Yes. It fades with each wash, usually within several weeks, depending on the shade and how often you wash.


Share post on
Sarah Jay
By Sarah Jay

Sarah Jay is a beautician that loves to write about the fashion and beauty industry. This love of writing led her to start her own blog, where she shares articles on everything from hair care tips to how-to guides. She's also passionate about gadgets, and has knowledge of the latest trends in her field. Sarah knows what people want when it comes to caring for their skin and hair.



Latest Posts

Best Waterproof Self Tanner: 10 Long-Lasting Picks ComparedBuying Guides

Best Waterproof Self Tanner: 10 Long-Lasting Picks Compared

Short answer: no self tanner is truly "waterproof", but you do not need one....

By Sarah Jay
•
Updated
Zero Gravity Pedicure: What It Is, What It Costs and Is It Worth ItKnowledge Base

Zero Gravity Pedicure: What It Is, What It Costs and Is It Worth It

A zero gravity pedicure is a pedicure done in a reclining lounger that tips...

By Sarah Jay
•
Updated
Spray Tan After Waxing: How Long Should You Wait?Tips

Spray Tan After Waxing: How Long Should You Wait?

Short answer: wait at least 24 hours after waxing before you get a spray...

By Sarah Jay
•
Updated
Can You Go Swimming After Waxing? How Long to WaitKnowledge Base

Can You Go Swimming After Waxing? How Long to Wait

Short answer: wait at least 24 hours before swimming after a wax, and 48...

By Sarah Jay
•
Updated
How to Dye Your Hair Jet Black at Home (Step by Step)Tips

How to Dye Your Hair Jet Black at Home (Step by Step)

Short answer: to dye your hair jet black at home, choose a permanent black...

By Sarah Jay
•
Updated
How Much Does a Pedicure Cost? Price Guide by TypeKnowledge Base

How Much Does a Pedicure Cost? Price Guide by Type

Short answer: a basic pedicure in the US usually costs about $25 to $50,...

By Sarah Jay
•
Updated
Do Blow Dryers Damage Your Hair? Heat Styling and BreakageKnowledge Base

Do Blow Dryers Damage Your Hair? Heat Styling and Breakage

Short answer: a blow dryer can dry out your hair and make it snap...

By Sarah Jay
•
Updated
Which Hair Extensions Are the Least Damaging? (Ranked)Knowledge Base

Which Hair Extensions Are the Least Damaging? (Ranked)

Short answer: halo and clip-in extensions are the least damaging because you take them...

By Sarah Jay
•
Updated